Does the H-1B Visa Harm American Workers?
The practice of hiring foreign labor under the H-1B visa program has been a controversial topic in the United States for years. Those who support the practice of outsourcing say that it is necessary for U.S. companies to hire foreign workers, since they cannot do as well as job filling jobs that require at least American degrees. Critics of this practice argue that it is not a fair immigration practice, since foreign professionals often bring their families with them and cannot provide household support. The government’s failure to acknowledge the negative impacts of the practice on the native population is what’s driving the increased interest in programs such as the newly implemented H-1B visa- main d’oeuvre étrangère
While it is true that foreign professionals have made our nation a better place overall by taking skilled jobs that are not readily available within our borders, it is also true that they have created their own culture and society. Many foreign professionals live in fear of being dislocated from their home country, which often leads to counterproductive actions by the U.S. government. It is important to understand that many foreign professionals feel that they are not being treated equally by our government. For instance, there have been reports of abuse against foreign professionals by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). There have also been reports of crimes committed by foreign professionals against Americans.
There is no real way to measure whether or not the H-1B visa process negatively impacts local employment. Many experts feel that although the H-1B visa program definitely hurts American businesses and hurts the native population, the negative impact is so minimal that it is hardly noticeable. Those who support the H-1B visa believe that the abuse of the visa system is due to a lack of education on the part of U.S. immigration authorities. For these reasons, they argue that reforms are needed to make the visa process more strictly monitored and controlled. Meanwhile, those who are opposed to the H-1B visa believe that it is detrimental to American labor.